Gypsy Soup from The New Moosewood Cookbook

I went to the library yesterday and checked out a few cookbooks. It’s a great way to explore the books you think might be worth purchasing or just find a few new recipes you like and then take the book back until you want it again.

One of the books I’ve heard is quite good is the vegetarian The New Moosewood Cookbook by Mollie Katzen. I was looking for a new soup for my “soup and sandwich Sunday” theme… I substituted canned tomatoes for fresh, used a can of garbanzo beans (aren’t they the same as chickpeas?), and added a carrot.

The soup was good…but I think next time I’ll cut down on the turmeric and perhaps leave out the cinnamon.

Print Recipe
4.80 from 5 votes

Gypsy Soup from Moosewood

Ingredients

  • 1 Tbs oil
  • 2 small onions, diced about 2 cups
  • 2 large cloves garlic, minced
  • 1 stalk celery, diced
  • 1 sweet potato, peeled and diced about 2 cups
  • 1 carrot, diced
  • 1 tsp salt
  • 1 tsp paprika
  • 1 tsp turmeric although I’d leave this out or lessen next time
  • 1 tsp dried basil
  • a dash of cinnamon optional
  • 1 bay leaf
  • 3 cups water
  • 1 can garbanzo beans, drained and rinsed
  • 1 small green pepper, seeded and diced
  • 1 can diced tomatoes, with juice

Instructions

  • Saute the onion, celery, sweet potato, and carrot in the oil for about 10 minutes, stirring occasionally. Add the salt, paprika, turmeric (if using), basil, cinnamon (if using), bay leaf, and water. Bring to a simmer, cover, and cook until everything is soft, about 15 minutes.
  • Add the garbanzo beans, green pepper, and tomatoes. Cover and simmer another 10 minutes or so, until everything is as soft as you like.

I found this a bit sweet, perhaps the turmeric and cinnamon. Perhaps my addition of carrot influenced that as well. The green peppers were still a bit crunchy, which made a nice contrast with everything else. I’m used to making soup with chicken broth, so perhaps I’d like this better with chicken broth. It was good, just not great.


Posted

in

,

by

Comments

20 responses to “Gypsy Soup from The New Moosewood Cookbook”

  1. Ellen Avatar

    I wonder if there were different editions of the cookbook with variations. I don’t have mine anymore.

  2. Kristina Church Avatar
    Kristina Church

    5 stars
    So good! I’ve made this soup a thousand times, never the same way twice. Today I was craving Gypsy soup but didn’t want to go to the store for any ingredients. So I used the remainder of a bag of shallots instead of onions, and since I had no celery, I sauteed my roots along with half a bunch of Italian parsley, chopped up. I used one large sweet potato plus a little delicata squash that had been hanging around all winter. I dumped in some turkey broth that was sitting in the fridge from an instant pot meal. No bell peppers, so in went a bag of broccoli florets. Instead of a can of chopped tomatoes I added some basil marinara leftover from a pasta meal. Some day-old Italian bread got cut up & fried into butter & herb crouton toppers. Made with these odds & ends, it was probably my best version of this soup yet! (I’ve never used a cinnamon stick in this before, just ground cinnamon– but it was sooo yummy. I’ll do that again for sure!)

  3. SBer Avatar
    SBer

    The recipe as presented here is not faithful to the original. The original is fabulous using stock. Some variations include using Smokey paprika and/ or homemade pesto instead of basil. The tamari is essential, as is the additional olive oil called for in the original. Yes, carrot makes it sweeter.

  4. Ellen Avatar

    I’ll have to give it a try with vegetable broth!

  5. Angela Avatar
    Angela

    I’ve made this soup and agree that it’s just ‘okay’…when made with water. Chicken broth, imo, isn’t right for it either. However! Making it with a good flavorful vegetable broth makes it truly excellent. It also keeps it vegan for those that are, but it gives it that something that is just perfect withe rest of the ingredients.

  6. Marci Avatar
    Marci

    5 stars
    I added cumin, a whole lemon, and corn. Perfecto

  7. Jennifer Avatar
    Jennifer

    I grew up on this soup. To each their own but this is not even gypsy soup without the turmeric.

  8. jessica Avatar
    jessica

    4 stars
    I like this soup better with vegetable broth and I add in curry powder with the tumeric. overall its a great recipe just lacked some good flavor with water. so if vegetarian use veggi broth if not use chicken. I feel this recipe was a guide. you can always tweak it

  9. Ellen Avatar

    Well, because I’m not a vegetarian and I think it would taste better.

  10. Chef Avatar
    Chef

    The point is that it’s a vegetarian dish why add chicken broth?

  11. Ellen Avatar

    That sounds good!

  12. Concetta Avatar
    Concetta

    5 stars
    I substitute butternut squash for sweet potato. First made this recipe in the 1970s. Still making and enjoying it with no major changes.

  13. Ellen Avatar

    I no longer have the cookbook but will try the soy sauce next time!

  14. Emilia Brasier Avatar

    The recipe we have (and we actually know the owner of Moosewood), has a tablespoon of tamari/soy sauce. We also always use vegetable broth and add a cup of kale at the end. The tamari/soy sauce really adds a lot for me.

  15. Phyllis Avatar
    Phyllis

    I always use the cinnamon, hungarian paprika and tumeric and always use a vegetable broth along with a vegetable bouillon to strengthen the flavor of the broth then you have no need for chicken. The seasoning gives it the gypdy/greek flavor that makes it so wonderful!! I’m no fan of sweet potatoes so I use new potatoes or baby yukons along with carrots to replace the sweet potatoes and have had no complaints. I never have any leftovers! I serve with sour dough. I alwaus add chopped yp chard or spinach which is in the original recipe but I noticed missing in a lot of the adapted versions!

  16. Ellen Avatar

    I almost always use chicken broth as well.

  17. Ellen Avatar

    I hope you like it!

  18. Lorraine Avatar
    Lorraine

    5 stars
    I obsessed about this recipe for years trying different variations. It is my Favorite Recipe. Make a vat of it. It will taste better every day.

    I’m back to soups and vegetarian eating, although I think using a chicken bone broth as the base adds a lovely richness. Garlic and that bay leaf is essential. I’ve used oregano, thyme, and rosemary along with the basil.

    I’ve never used paprika, turmeric and cinnamon, but I may try it! It’s such a happy soup along with some fresh sourdough bread!

  19. […] Gypsy Soup from Moosewood […]

  20. Dr. Alice Avatar
    Dr. Alice

    I love to check out cookbooks at the library! Good reading there. It also helps me figure out which books I actually want to buy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.